收稿日期: 2024-02-19
网络出版日期: 2024-06-12
基金资助
国家自然科学基金(82173637)
Application of the cigarette purchase tasks in achieving China' s tobacco control goals
Received date: 2024-02-19
Online published: 2024-06-12
Supported by
the National Natural Science Foundation of China(82173637)
目的: 采用卷烟购买任务(cigarette purchase task,CPT)对我国吸烟者的卷烟需求进行评价,并评估不同假设情境下的卷烟价格,以实现“健康中国2030”行动中降低吸烟率的目标。方法: 共计447名受试者通过问卷调查完成CPT,根据价格框架和对应的卷烟消费量拟合卷烟需求曲线,并得到5个相关指标,分别为强度(免费时的卷烟消费量)、断点(消费量降为0的价格)、最高消费额(maximum output, Omax)、最高价格(maximum price, Pmax, 最高消费额对应的卷烟价格)和弹性(消费量变化与价格变化的比率)。采用单因素分析探索CPT指标和社会人口学特征、吸烟特征的相关性。采用单相衰减模型拟合戒烟率-卷烟价格曲线,并确定一系列情境下能使吸烟率降到20%的最佳卷烟价格。结果: 从卷烟需求曲线得到吸烟者弹性为0.54,表明价格上涨10%可使吸烟率降低5.4%。收入越高的吸烟者对卷烟价格敏感性越低(弹性=-2.31, P=0.028)。CPT指标在常用卷烟价格、吸烟量和烟草依赖程度不同的吸烟者中差异有统计学意义,常用卷烟价格越高的吸烟者断点、最高消费额和最高价格均越高,弹性越低(P=0.001),烟草依赖程度越高的吸烟者强度、断点、最高消费额和最高价格均越高,而弹性越低(P=0.001),吸烟量更大的吸烟者强度、最高消费额更高,弹性更低(P < 0.001)。要实现将吸烟率降至20% 的目标,卷烟的价格至少为37.36元/包,调整受教育水平和收入水平后,卷烟价格分别至少为37.37元/包和37.84元/包。结论: CPT指标与收入水平和常用卷烟价格、吸烟量和烟草依赖程度显著相关,在研究影响吸烟行为的价格因素方面有应用空间;本研究模型拟合卷烟价格远超当前实际市场水平,应采取更有力的政策措施提高烟草税和卷烟零售价,以实现将吸烟率降低到20%的“健康中国2030”目标。
杨晓尘 , 曹望楠 , 林昊翔 , 张蓝超 , 林雨欣 , 陈子砚 , 常春 . CPT在实现我国控烟目标中的应用探索[J]. 北京大学学报(医学版), 2024 , 56(3) : 479 -486 . DOI: 10.19723/j.issn.1671-167X.2024.03.015
Objective: To assess cigarette demand among Chinese smokers through a cigarette purchase task (CPT) and to evaluate cigarette prices under different hypothetical scenarios in order to meet the goals of smoking prevalence reduction in China. Methods: In the study, 447 participants completed a hypothetical CPT at baseline assessments of a trial, thus, cigarette demand curves were individually fitted for each participant using an exponentiated version of the exponential demand model. Typically, five demand indices were derived, intensity (consumption when free), breakpoint (first price at which consumption is suppressed to 0), maximum output (Omax), maximum price (Pmax, price at which Omax occurred), and elasticity (the ratio of the change in quantity demanded to the change in price). A one-way analysis of variance was used to explore the correlations between the cigarette purchase task indices and socio-demographic and smoking characteristics. The one-way decay model was employed to simulate the smoking cessation rates and determine optimal cigarette prices in a series of scenarios for achieving 20% smoking prevalence. Results: The price elasticity drawn from CPT was 0.54, indicating that a 10% price increase could reduce smoking by 5.4% in the participated smokers. Smokers with higher income were less sensitive to cigarette prices (elasticity=-2.31, P=0.028). Cigarette purchase task indices varied significantly among the smokers with different prices of commonly used cigarettes, tobacco dependence, and smoking volume. The smokers who consumed cigarettes of higher prices reported higher breakpoint, Omax and Pmax, but lower intensity (P=0.001). The smokers who were moderately or highly nicotine dependent reported higher intensity, breakpoint, Omax and Pmax, and they had lower intensity (P=0.001). The smokers who had a higher volume of cigarettes reported higher intensity and Omax, and lower intensity (P < 0.001). To achieve the goal of reducing smoking prevalence to 20% in mainland China, we estimated the desired increase on smoking cessation rate and prices accordingly in a series of scenarios, considering the gender variance and reduced smoking initiation. In scenario (a), to achieve a smoking prevalence goal of 20%, it would be necessary for 24.81% of the current smokers to quit smoking when there were no new smokers. Our fitting model yielded a corresponding value of 59.64 yuan (95%CI 53.13-67.24). Given the assumption in scenario (b) that only males quitted smoking, the desired cessation rates would be 25.82%, with a higher corresponding price of 62.15 yuan (95%CI 55.40-70.06) to induce desired cessation rates. In the proposed scenario (c) where 40 percent of the reduction in smoking prevalence came from reduced smoking initiation, and females and males equally quitted smoking due to increased cigarette prices, the price of a pack of cigarettes would be at least 37.36 yuan (95%CI 32.32-42.69) (equals to $ 5.20) per pack to achieve the cessation rate of 14.89 percent. In scenario (d) where only males quitted smoking due to increased cigarette prices considering the reduced smoking initiation, the respective smoking cessation rates should be 15.49% with the desired prices of 38.60 yuan (95%CI 33.53-44.02). After adjusting for education levels and income levels in scenario (c), the price of cigarettes would be at least 37.37 yuan/pack (equals to $ 5.20) (95%CI 30.73-44.94) and 37.84 yuan/pack (equals to $ 5.26) (95%CI 31.94-44.53), respectively. Conclusion: Cigarette purchase task indices are significantly associated with income levels and prices of commonly used cigarettes, levels of tobacco dependence, and smoking volume, which is inspiring in studying price factors that influence smoking behavior. It is suggested that higher cigarette prices, surpassing the current actual market level, is imperative in mainland China. Stronger policy stra-tegies should be taken to increase tobacco taxes and retail cigarette prices to achieve the Healthy China 2030 goal of reducing smoking prevalence to 20%.
Key words: Cigarette demand; Cigarette purchase task; Tobacco control; Tobacco tax
| 1 | The Tobacco Control Office of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention. 2018 China adult tobacco survey report[EB/OL]. (2019-09-23)[2023-11-20]. https://cdn.who.int/media/docs/default-source/ncds/ncd-surveillance/data-reporting/china/2018-china-adult-tobacco-survey-report_eng.pdf. |
| 2 | Mark G , Rong Z .Tobacco control and Healthy China 2030[J].Tobacco Control,2019,28(4):409. |
| 3 | Atkinson AB , Townsend JL .Economic aspects of reduced smoking[J].Lancet,1977,2(8036):492-495. |
| 4 | World Health Organization. World Health Organization fact sheets. Tobacco[EB/OL]. (2023-07-31)[2023-11-20]. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/tobacco. |
| 5 | World Health Organization. WHO report on the global tobacco epidemic, 2023[EB/OL]. (2023-07-31)[2023-09-20]. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240077164. |
| 6 | 郑韵婷, 林昊翔, 云青萍, 等.控烟政策背景下北京市卷烟价格、可负担性及价格对卷烟需求的影响[J].现代预防医学,2021,48(10):1830-1833. |
| 7 | 谢莉, 姜垣.健康中国必将是无烟中国[J].中国慢性病预防与控制,2019,27(7):481-483. |
| 8 | Yang G , Wang Y , Wu Y , et al.The road to effective tobacco control in China[J].Lancet,2015,385(9972):1019-1028. |
| 9 | Mackillop J , Murphy JG , Ray LA , et al.Further validation of a cigarette purchase task for assessing the relative reinforcing efficacy of nicotine in college smokers[J].Exp Clin Psychopharmacol,2008,16(1):57-65. |
| 10 | Murphy JG , Mackillop J .Relative reinforcing efficacy of alcohol among college student drinkers[J].Exp Clin Psychopharmacol,2006,14(2):219-227. |
| 11 | Reed DD , Naudé GP , Salzer AR , et al.Behavioral economic measurement of cigarette demand: A descriptive review of published approaches to the cigarette purchase task[J].Exp Clin Psychopharmacol,2020,28(6):688-705. |
| 12 | Mead-Morse EL , Cassidy RN , Oncken C , et al.Validity of a little cigars/cigarillos purchase task in dual users of cigars and cigarettes[J].Addict Behav,2022,130,107285. |
| 13 | González-Roz A , Secades-Villa R , Weidberg S , et al.Latent structure of the cigarette purchase task among treatment-seeking smokers with depression and its predictive validity on smoking abstinence[J].Nicotine Tob Res,2020,22(1):74-80. |
| 14 | Chase HW , Mackillop J , Hogarth L .Isolating behavioural economic indices of demand in relation to nicotine dependence[J].Psychopharmacology (Berl),2013,226(2):371-380. |
| 15 | Evemy CG , Kurti AN , Skelly JM , et al.Examining the latent factor structure of a hypothetical cigarette purchase task among pregnant women[J].Exp Clin Psychopharmacol,2023,31(1):23-28. |
| 16 | Salhi L , Seidel L , Albert A , et al.Fagerstr?m test for nicotine dependence as an indicator in tobacco-related studies in periodontology[J].J Periodontol,2021,92(2):298-305. |
| 17 | Glasheen C , Johnson EO , Saccone NL , et al.Is the Fagerstr?m test for nicotine dependence invariant across secular trends in smoking? A question for cross-birth cohort analysis of nicotine dependence[J].Drug Alcohol Depend,2018,185,127-132. |
| 18 | 李赋, 李毅, 郭怡阳, 等.尼古丁依赖检测量表在男性吸烟精神分裂症住院患者中的试测[J].中国心理卫生杂志,2017,31(8):630-634. |
| 19 | Jacobs EA , Bickel WK .Modeling drug consumption in the clinic using simulation procedures: Demand for heroin and cigarettes in opioid-dependent outpatients[J].Exp Clin Psychopharmacol,1999,7(4):412-426. |
| 20 | Stein JS , Koffarnus MN , Snider SE , et al.Identification and management of nonsystematic purchase task data: Toward best practice[J].Exp Clin Psychopharmacol,2015,23(5):377-386. |
| 21 | Secades-Villa R , Pericot-Valverde I , Weidberg S .Relative reinforcing efficacy of cigarettes as a predictor of smoking abstinence among treatment-seeking smokers[J].Psychopharmacology,2016,233(17):3103-3112. |
| 22 | Méndez D , Le TT , Warner KE .Monitoring the increase in the U.S. smoking cessation rate and its implication for future smoking prevalence[J].Nicotine Tob Res,2022,24(11):1727-1731. |
| 23 | Liu H , Rizzo JA , Sun Q , et al.How do smokers respond to cigarette taxes? Evidence from China' s cigarette industry[J].Health Econ,2015,24(10):1314-1330. |
| 24 | 郑榕, 崔凤."健康中国2030"控烟目标的实现与烟草消费税改革路径[J].国际税收,2022,(9):57-64. |
| 25 | Chen Z , Peto R , Zhou M , et al.Contrasting male and female trends in tobacco-attributed mortality in China: evidence from successive nationwide prospective cohort studies[J].Lancet,2015,386(10002):1447-1456. |
| 26 | Verguet S , Gauvreau CL , Mishra S , et al.The consequences of tobacco tax on household health and finances in rich and poor smokers in China: An extended cost-effectiveness analysis[J].Lancet Glob Health,2015,3(4):e206-e216. |
| 27 | Kostova D , Husain MJ , Chaloupka FJ .Effect of cigarette prices on smoking initiation and cessation in China: A duration analysis[J].Tob Control,2016,26(5):569-574. |
| 28 | Goodchild M , Zheng R .Early assessment of China' s 2015 tobacco tax increase[J].Bull World Health Organ,2018,96(7):506-512. |
| 29 | World Health Organization. WHO technical manual on tobacco tax policy and administration[EB/OL]. (2021-04-12)[2023-09-20]. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240019188. |
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |